You have permission to edit this article.
Less is probably more

Less is probably more

  • 0

When President Donald Trump announced his plan to relocate a few dozen U.S. soldiers in Syria -- getting them out of the way of a pending Turkish invasion -- the Washington establishment exploded in rage at what it mischaracterized as a U.S. "withdrawal" from Syria.

Fear of Mondale moment

Instead of fighting that mischaracterization, Trump embraced it, pretending that an actual withdrawal was in progress and announcing on Oct. 9 that "we're bringing our folks back home."

If he's telling the truth, hooray! But so far as I can discern, no, he isn't telling the truth.

Since taking office (after campaigning on getting the U.S. out of military quagmires in the Middle East and Central Asia), Trump has boosted U.S. troop levels in Syria from 500 or fewer under Barack Obama to at least 2,000 and possibly as many as 4,000.

Even at its most ambitious, the supposed U.S. "withdrawal" from Syria consisted of moving a few hundred soldiers across the border into Iraq, from which they could launch operations in Syria at will.

Down side of impeachment

The Iraqi government objected to hosting more U.S. troops on its soil, so now the plan has changed to deploying elements of an armored brigade combat team ("less than a battalion," so call it "less than a thousand troops" depending on what kind of battalion) to protect Syrian oil fields from the Islamic State (and from Syria's own government).

Exactly how many U.S. soldiers, sailors, airmen and Marines were in Syria prior to the supposed withdrawal? How many are there now? How many will be there by the end of the year?

That's hard to say with any exactitude. Over the last several years (and not just on Trump's watch), the U.S. government's troop level claims have become less specific and more general, less matters of public record and more notional state secrets.

But so far, according to those claims, Trump has escalated U.S. involvement in every conflict he inherited from Obama, even after promising to do the opposite and even while pretending to do the opposite.

If past performance is an indicator of future results, what's going on in Syria isn't a U.S. withdrawal at all. Instead of U.S. forces departing the country, more troops and heavier weapons seem to be flowing into the country (and the region, including B-1B bombers to Saudi Arabia).

Will Trump's non-interventionist supporters finally notice or admit that, as usual, his rhetoric and his actions don't match? Fat chance.

Thomas L. Knapp (Twitter: @thomaslknapp) is director and senior news analyst at the William Lloyd Garrison Center for Libertarian Advocacy Journalism ( He lives and works in north central Florida.


Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Alongside traffic and coffee, news radio is a staple of my morning commute. As I flip through the stations, I'll sometime hear a pundit lament…

The U.S. House of Representatives soberly fulfills its constitutional obligation to investigate alleged wrongdoing by a sitting president, ste…

"Wasting resources, capital and income on stuff nobody really needs," Charles Hugh Smith wrote in 2017, "is a monumental disaster on multiple …

Annie Karni, Maggie Haberman, and Sheila Kaplan of the New York Times describe President Donald Trump's proposed ban on flavored e-cigarette p…

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News