Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
top story

Two arrested in Holly Hill quadruple homicide

From the Anniversary of Holly Hill Mass Shooting series
  • 0
Scott and Coleman

After more than a year of effort, two men are reportedly facing murder charges in the 2015 Holly Hill quadruple homicide.

U.S. Marshals arrested Derrick Warren Coleman, 27, and Antly Jermaine “Jackie Man” Scott, 35, in Foley, Alabama, on Tuesday according to WKRG, a TV news station in Alabama. They’d been living there for a short time.

Coleman and Scott were arrested on murder charges and are awaiting extradition to South Carolina, according to the WKRG report.

“Acting on a tip, U.S. Marshals surrounded the house, guns drawn. Coleman was taken into custody Monday. Twelve hours later, the marshals were back to take Scott into custody on murder warrants in connection with the Holly Hill case,” WKRG reported.

Coleman grew up in Baldwin County, Alabama, the station reported. In 2009, he was severely injured in a motorcycle accident where he was trapped under a burning car. Good Samaritans saved his life.

Baldwin County Detention Center booking sheets show the two are both from Eutawville.

A press conference is planned for noon Thursday in the July 15, 2015 deaths of Jerome Butler, 50; Krystal Hutto, 28; and half-sisters Shamekia Tyjuana Sanders, 17, and Tamara Alexis Perry, 14.

Dreamzz Nelson, 8, was also shot. He survived.

Each of the victims was shot execution-style at 7050 Old State Road in Holly Hill.

Butler’s body was found next to a BMW in the driveway of the home.

In one of the bedrooms, Hutto’s lifeless body was discovered.

Sanders and Perry were found in another bedroom.

Nelson was also discovered in a bedroom and transported by helicopter to a Charleston-area hospital. He’s since made a steady recovery.

During an interview this past July, Orangeburg County Sheriff Leroy Ravenell said that deputies and investigators spent more than 20,000 man-hours on the case and conducted at least 200 interviews.

Ravenell updated the families of the victims about the arrests on Wednesday, according to a family member.

The father of the teens and the 8-year-old, Christopher Dean Wright, is relieved that justice is continuing to be sought in the case, according to attorney David Williams.

Williams said Wright is aware of the arrests.

Wright, who has not been charged in the shootings, has been held at the Orangeburg County Detention Center since last fall.

He faces two drug trafficking charges, three unlawful conduct toward a child charges and one charge each of obstruction of justice and trafficking cocaine.

On the one-year anniversary of the slayings this past July, community members marched for justice from the home where the slayings occurred to the Holly Hill municipal complex.

Ravenell told The T&D in July that he keeps a bulletin board, perched on an easel, next to his desk.

On the bulletin board are several clippings from The T&D about the quadruple homicide.

He said he’s keeping the bulletin board there until the case is solved.

“Last year at Christmastime, staff tried to put a Christmas tree in here, but I didn’t have any room for it because of this,” he said.

“Hopefully this year I’m going to be able to put up a Christmas tree.”

Contact the writer: or 803-533-5545. Follow on Twitter: @MRBrownTandD.


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Full press conference by Orangeburg County Sheriff Leroy Ravenell on the Holly Hill quadruple homicide.

Two people have been accused of obstructing an investigation into the execution-style deaths of four people in Holly Hill.

Family and friends of the victims of last year's quadruple murder march in their memory Friday evening, July 15, on U.S. 176 outside Holly Hill.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News